← All lessons

Choosing among CROD, CBAR, and CBEAM

Choose rod or beam elements based on the deformation and section properties you need to represent.

Decide whether the member must carry bending

CROD transmits axial force and torsion. For a cantilever whose bending deformation matters, consider CBAR or CBEAM. Before replacing a card, identify the forces and moments the member must transmit.

Check the beam axes and section properties

With both CBAR and CBEAM, the element orientation affects how you interpret results. If section properties need to vary along the element, consider CBEAM and its corresponding property entry. Check the fields supported by your product, release, and solution.

Keep loads and supports fixed during comparison

Use the same material, section, length, loads, and supports. Compare tip displacement, section forces, reactions, and deformation direction. This helps you tell whether a difference comes from the element formulation or a change in the input.

Reference: Hexagon MSC Nastran documentation

Next lesson → Reading F06 output and checking results